At some point in every tired kitchen the same question comes up: is it worth replacing the doors, or should we just do the whole thing? The two options are not really competing, because they solve different problems. This is how to work out which problem you have.
What each one actually changes
| Question | New doors | New kitchen |
|---|---|---|
| How it looks | Transformed | Transformed |
| Where things are | Unchanged | Anything is possible |
| Storage you get | Unchanged | Can be improved |
| Failing carcasses | Still failing | Replaced |
| Plumbing and electrics | Untouched | Usually reworked |
| Trades needed | None, if you are handy | Several, in sequence |
| Kitchen out of action | Not really | Days to weeks |
| Cost | A fraction | The full amount |
Read down the two columns and the decision usually makes itself. If every row that matters to you says unchanged in the doors column, you want a kitchen.
The question that decides it
Ask yourself what is actually wrong with the kitchen.
If the honest answer is some version of “it looks dated” or “I have never liked the colour”, that is a doors job and a very satisfying one.
If the honest answer involves the word where, as in where the bin is, where the oven is, where there is nowhere to put the kettle down, that is a layout problem and doors will not touch it.
If the honest answer is that things are breaking, look at what is breaking. Hinges and drawer runners are cheap and replaceable. Carcasses are not.
The hidden costs of a new kitchen
A new kitchen is not the quoted price of the units. The things that get added afterwards are usually:
- Fitting, often comparable to the units themselves
- Plumbing and electrical work, especially if anything moves
- Making good the walls and ceiling where the old units were
- Flooring, because the old floor stops at the old units
- Decorating afterwards
- Appliances, which rarely survive a redesign unchanged
- Eating out, or living off a microwave in the hall, for the duration
None of these appear on a door order.
The hidden costs of new doors
In fairness, there are some, and they are the lines people leave off their own estimate:
- End panels for every exposed carcass side
- Plinth, cornice and pelmet, which will not match if you keep the old ones
- Handles for every front
- Hinges, if the old ones are worn
- Your own weekend
Leave these out and the job looks half done. Put them in and it looks like a new kitchen.
The case for doing both, in order
There is a third answer people rarely consider. If a new kitchen is right but not right now, new doors buy you several years of a kitchen you like for a small fraction of the cost, and the carcasses were going in the skip anyway.
That only works if the carcasses have those years in them. It is a sensible move in a house you are staying in and a poor one in a kitchen that is already failing.
When doors are clearly the answer
- The carcasses are sound
- The layout works
- The complaint is visual
- You would rather spend the difference on something else
- You cannot face being without a kitchen
When a new kitchen is clearly the answer
- Several carcasses are swollen, sagging or moving
- The layout fights you every day
- You want different units, not different fronts
- The wiring or the plumbing needs doing anyway
- You are planning to change the room, not just the kitchen
Frequently asked questions
Can I replace doors and the worktop together?
Yes, and it is the most common upgrade there is. Between them the doors and the worktop are nearly everything you see, so doing both gets you most of the way to a new kitchen for a long way short of the price. We sell both.
Will new doors fit if my kitchen is very old?
If it uses concealed hinges in 35mm holes, almost certainly. Frame built kitchens and anything with exposed hinges need a conversation first. Ring 01206 616626 and describe what you have.
Is it worth getting a fitter for doors?
Not usually, if you are comfortable with a screwdriver and willing to spend time adjusting. It is worth it if you are also fitting new hinges, panels and trims, or if you would rather it were someone else’s problem.
What about the carcasses underneath, cosmetically?
You see very little of them once the doors are on. The parts you do see are the exposed ends, which is what end panels are for.