Replacing the doors is one of those jobs that is either obviously right or obviously wrong once you look at the kitchen properly. This is how to tell which one you have.
The case for
You are paying for the part you can see
In a fitted kitchen, the carcasses are boxes. They are rarely the thing anyone dislikes. The doors, the handles and the worktop are what the room looks like, and doors are the largest share of that by area.
The kitchen stays usable
A door swap does not involve ripping anything out. The sink stays plumbed, the oven stays wired, and you can stop halfway through and have dinner. A new kitchen means a week or more of not having one.
No trades to coordinate
New doors need a screwdriver and some patience. A new kitchen needs a fitter, usually a plumber, often an electrician, sometimes a plasterer, and all of them in the right order.
Less waste
A sound carcass that goes to landfill because the doors looked dated is a bad outcome by any measure.
The case against
If the carcasses have had it
Swollen chipboard, sagging shelves, units that move when you pull on them, a sink base that has been wet for years. New doors on failing boxes is money spent on a problem you still have.
If the layout is the problem
Doors change how a kitchen looks and nothing about how it works. If the real complaint is that there is no worktop next to the hob, or that the fridge door blocks the walkway, this is not the fix.
If you want to change the units
Different size units, a new island, a bank of drawers where a cupboard was, any of that is a new kitchen whatever you do about the doors.
If you are moving next year
A tired kitchen is priced into an offer. So is a new one, usually at less than it cost. If the move is close, a deep clean and new handles may be the better spend.
The test
Open every cupboard in the kitchen and look at the inside rather than the outside. Press the base of the sink unit. Pull on a shelf. Look at the back panels.
If the boxes are solid and the layout works, new doors are a good decision and you will be pleased with it. If several boxes are failing, or you keep finding yourself redesigning the room in your head while you look, the answer is a new kitchen and the doors will not talk you out of it.
What makes the difference between a good job and an obvious one
Where door replacements go wrong is almost never the doors.
- Old plinth. New doors above a scuffed plinth read as new doors above a scuffed plinth.
- Old handles. The cheapest way to keep the kitchen looking like the kitchen you were replacing.
- Exposed carcass ends. An uncovered side panel next to a new door is the first thing a visitor sees.
- Doors not adjusted. Uneven gaps make good doors look like a botch. It is twenty minutes with a screwdriver.
- Worktop left behind. If the worktop is the tired element, new doors will make it look worse rather than better.
Budget for the trims and the handles from the start and the result looks like a new kitchen. Leave them out and it looks like new doors.
A middle option worth knowing about
You do not have to do the whole room at once. Doing the run you look at most, or the island, and leaving the utility or the back wall until later, is a legitimate way to spread the cost. The thing to be aware of is that a door made in a year’s time will not be an exact batch match for one made now, so plan the split along a visual break rather than through the middle of a run.
Frequently asked questions
How much cheaper is it than a new kitchen?
Substantially, and the gap widens the more the new kitchen would involve. The doors are a fraction of a full replacement, and you avoid the fitting, the trades and the disruption entirely.
Will it add value to the house?
A kitchen that looks cared for helps a sale. Whether the spend comes back pound for pound depends on the house and the market, and nobody can promise you that it will.
Can I do it myself?
If you can use a screwdriver and a tape measure, yes. The skill is in the measuring beforehand and the adjusting afterwards, not in the fitting.
What if I am not sure which category my kitchen is in?
Ring 01206 616626 and describe it. We would rather tell you it is not worth doing than sell you doors for a kitchen that needs replacing.